Lisandro Martinez’s future at Manchester United could be in jeopardy following comments from Ruben Amorim that cast doubt on the defender’s role in the squad. Amorim’s remarks suggest uncertainty about Martinez’s position, raising questions about his long-term place within the team’s defensive lineup.

Lisandro Martinez’s future at Manchester United appears uncertain as questions continue to arise about his performances since his return from injury. His debut season in England was nothing short of exceptional, with many lauding him as one of the club’s finest signings in the post-Sir Alex Ferguson era. However, the narrative has shifted significantly since his comeback, with his form dipping below the high standards he set upon his arrival.

Martinez’s fortunes took a turn following a leg injury sustained in April 2023 during a 2-2 draw against Sevilla. Since recovering, he has struggled to recapture the defensive dominance that characterized his early days at Old Trafford. The Argentine center-back, brought in by Erik ten Hag for £57 million from Ajax in 2022, was expected to be a cornerstone of United’s defense. His left-footed abilities, composure on the ball, and leadership qualities seemed tailor-made for success, particularly in Ruben Amorim’s three-at-the-back system. Yet, recent performances have cast doubt on his long-term role within the team.

At 26 years old, Martinez should be entering his prime. However, his display against Nottingham Forest raised alarms. He was outmatched aerially by Nikola Milenkovic for Forest’s opening goal and later failed to react to Chris Wood’s decisive header, leaving fans and analysts questioning his reliability. Such moments have become increasingly frequent, leading to growing frustration among supporters at Old Trafford.

Meanwhile, other defenders have quickly adapted to Amorim’s system. Matthijs de Ligt has cemented his place as the central defensive leader, while young talent Leny Yoro, despite limited appearances, has shown promise and is expected to become a key figure by season’s end. Noussair Mazraoui, another summer signing, has also impressed, seamlessly transitioning between defensive and attacking roles. Amorim has openly praised Mazraoui’s versatility and technical skill, labeling him a vital part of the team’s future.

With competition for defensive spots intensifying, Martinez finds himself under pressure. Amorim’s glowing appraisal of players like Mazraoui and Yoro suggests they are integral to his vision, leaving Martinez in a precarious position. Unless he can regain the form that once made him a fan favorite, he risks being overshadowed by his teammates. As the season progresses, Martinez must prove his worth or face the possibility of losing his starting role to the emerging talents around him.