We’ve fallen into a habit of ridiculing NHL teams for hiring so-called “recycled” coaches. The league undeniably has a troubling pattern of circling back to the same names—often at the expense of fresh, deserving candidates. But that narrative can cloud judgment, especially when a veteran coach might be exactly what a team needs.
Take Rick Tocchet, for example.
Too often dismissed due to his age, lack of a Stanley Cup title as a head coach, or a spotty playoff record, Tocchet is precisely the kind of coach who could reignite the Pittsburgh Penguins. While some teams scour every corner of North America and Europe for the next coaching prodigy, the Penguins, Flyers, and Blackhawks would do well to give Tocchet serious consideration.
Consider Paul Maurice, head coach of the Florida Panthers. He was fired by both the Hurricanes and Maple Leafs and had stints with three different teams before finally finding success in Florida. Now, he’s led the Panthers to back-to-back Stanley Cup Final appearances, winning it all last season. He’s a recycled coach.
Craig Berube, now behind the bench in Toronto, has brought a jolt of energy to the Maple Leafs. Under his leadership, they look like legitimate contenders. He’s previously been dismissed by both the Flyers and Blues. Another recycled coach.
Dallas Stars coach Peter DeBoer has been fired three times, yet he’s guiding one of the most formidable teams in this year’s playoffs. Talent certainly helps, but coaching matters—and DeBoer is delivering.
Looking back at the most dominant post-lockout teams—Pittsburgh, Chicago, and Los Angeles—recycled coaches were at the helm. Mike Sullivan saved the Penguins from mediocrity and turned them into three-time champions. Joel Quenneville, recently hired by the Ducks, led Chicago to three Cups in six years after being let go by both the Blues and Avalanche. Darryl Sutter led the Kings to two Cups, having already coached in Calgary, San Jose, and Chicago.
Yes, “hotshot” coaches can win, too. There’s no one-size-fits-all approach. But to discount Tocchet because he hasn’t yet reached hockey’s summit is shortsighted. He worked wonders with the 2018-19 Coyotes—a team that lacked star power yet played disciplined, effective hockey under his leadership.
Tocchet, now 61, brings grit, experience, and a deep understanding of the modern NHL. His track record may not include a Cup as head coach—yet—but he’s proven he can maximize what he’s given.
The Penguins don’t need flash. They need someone who understands their identity and knows how to win when it matters. Rick Tocchet fits that bill.
Leave a Reply